In the Pacific Northwest, Idaho is known for its rugged terrain, endless outdoor opportunities, and welcoming communities. Nicknamed the “Gem State” for its rich resources and breathtaking landscapes, Idaho combines modern conveniences with a quieter way of life. From the energetic streets of Boise, the state’s capital, to the peaceful ambiance of Coeur d’Alene. However, life in Idaho does come with its share of challenges. This ApartmentGuide article will break down the pros and cons of living in Idaho, giving you a clear idea of what to anticipate.
Renting in Idaho snapshot
1. Pro: Full of natural wonders
Idaho is full of various landscapes, with destinations that cater to every level of adventurer. The rugged peaks of the Sawtooth Mountains are ideal for hiking and rock climbing, while the tranquil waters of Lake Coeur d’Alene is a great place for boating, fishing, and paddleboarding. Shoshone Falls, often called the “Niagara of the West,” offers breathtaking views and a chance to explore the Snake River Canyon. Additionally, the Frank Church-River of No Return Wilderness Area, one of the largest contiguous wilderness areas in the United States, provides miles of trails for backpacking and horseback riding.
2. Con: Public transportation options run short
Public transportation in Idaho can be a challenge, especially in rural areas where options are scarce or nonexistent. Larger cities like Boise provide some public transit, such as Valley Regional Transit buses, but coverage is often limited to central hubs, leaving outlying neighborhoods with fewer options. For instance, commuters in Boise’s West Bench area may find bus routes too infrequent or inconvenient for daily use. Smaller cities like Idaho Falls and Twin Falls have even fewer options, and rural areas rely almost entirely on personal vehicles. Without robust public transportation, residents often face increased costs for fuel, vehicle maintenance, and parking, making car ownership essential for most.
3. Pro: Affordable living attracts newcomers
Although the state’s median home sale price of $470,600 is higher than the national average, smaller cities like Pocatello offer even more affordable options, with median prices closer to $300,000. Renters can also find deals, such as one-bedroom apartments in Idaho Falls averaging $1,192 per month. Additionally, the cost of groceries, healthcare, and utilities tend to be less expensive than in neighboring states like Washington or Oregon. This affordability, combined with a slower-paced lifestyle, makes Idaho a good place to live for those seeking financial stability. If you’re just starting out, tools like a rental calculator can help you determine what fits your budget.
4. Con: Seasonal allergies disrupt outdoor fun
Idaho’s beautiful environment comes with a downside: seasonal allergies. Spring ushers in high pollen counts from trees like cottonwood, birch, and juniper, while summer and fall see spikes from grasses and weeds, particularly in agricultural areas. Residents in Boise, for example, often report heightened allergies during the Treasure Valley’s peak pollination periods.
5. Pro: Communities are welcoming
Idaho’s reputation for friendly communities is well-earned. In towns like Sandpoint, neighbors greet each other by name, and local events like farmers’ markets or community parades foster a sense of belonging. In McCall, residents and visitors come together for the Winter Carnival, a celebration featuring snow sculptures, fireworks, and live music. Whether you’re new to the area or a lifelong resident, Idahoans take pride in helping one another.
6. Con: Rural areas struggle with job opportunities
While Idaho’s economy has grown significantly in recent years, rural areas face limited job prospects. Boise’s thriving tech sector, anchored by companies like Micron Technology, offers opportunities for software developers and engineers, while the city’s medical facilities provide careers in healthcare. However, in smaller towns like Weiser or Orofino, options are often confined to agriculture, logging, or small local businesses. Job seekers in these regions may need to commute or relocate to access roles in specialized fields.
7. Pro: Traffic-free roads simplify daily life
One of the perks of living in Idaho is the ease of getting around, even in its busiest cities. In Boise, the average commute time is just 18 minutes, significantly shorter than in larger metropolitan areas. Idaho Falls and Coeur d’Alene also experience minimal congestion, allowing residents to travel efficiently without the stress of bumper-to-bumper traffic. Rural highways and scenic byways, like the Salmon River Scenic Route, not only make commuting a breeze but also provide breathtaking views.
8. Con: Winter weather brings harsh conditions
Idaho winters can be intense, especially in mountainous areas like Sun Valley or McCall, where snowfall often exceeds 100 inches annually. Residents must prepare for icy roads, subzero temperatures, and power outages caused by heavy snow. In cities like Pocatello, winter storms can disrupt commutes and make outdoor activities difficult. Despite these challenges, many residents embrace the season through skiing, snowboarding, and snowshoeing.
9. Pro: Seasons transform life and recreation
Idaho’s four seasons provide endless opportunities for recreation and enjoyment. Summer is perfect for rafting on the Snake River or hiking in the Sawtooth Mountains, while autumn brings bright foliage to places like the Boise Greenbelt. Additionally, the winters are full of activities including skiing and snowboarding at many destinations. Each season offers a distinct experience, whether it’s apple picking in the fall or fishing in the summer.
10. Con: High elevations challenge newcomers
Living in Idaho often means adjusting to high elevations, especially in areas like Ketchum and Hailey, which sit over 5,000 feet above sea level. These elevations can cause altitude sickness, with symptoms such as headaches, nausea, and shortness of breath, particularly for those unaccustomed to thinner air. Staying hydrated and acclimating slowly are crucial for newcomers.
11. Pro: Creativity flourishes here
Idaho’s arts scene is alive with creativity and expression. Sun Valley is a cultural hotspot, featuring art galleries, live performances, and events like the Sun Valley Film Festival. Boise’s Freak Alley Gallery showcases vibrant street art, while the city’s Philharmonic and Shakespeare Festival offer opportunities to experience music and theater. Smaller towns like Coeur d’Alene also contribute to the state’s cultural scene, hosting events like ArtWalk, which celebrates local artists.
12. Con: Wildfire risks loom over the summers
Wildfires are an unfortunate reality in Idaho, particularly during the dry summer months. Regions near Boise National Forest and the Sawtooth Wilderness are especially vulnerable, with fires often leading to evacuations and air quality issues. In 2021, the Snake River Complex Fire burned over 100,000 acres, highlighting the potential for widespread impact.
Methodology : The population data is from the United States Census Bureau, walkable cities are from Walk Score, and rental data is from Redfin.