Indianapolis, IN, is a quintessential Midwestern city, home to the Indy 500, the Indianapolis Colts, and historic landmarks like the Soldiers & Sailors Monument. With nearly 800K residents, there’s plenty to do on any given day – from enjoying the beautiful outdoors, seeing a concert, exploring a museum, or checking out Indy’s food scene.
If you’re looking to rent an apartment in Indianapolis, the average rent for a studio is $$1,163, while a one-bedroom is $$1,224. At ApartmentGuide, we’ve collected a list of the most affordable neighborhoods in Indianapolis. You’re sure to find the right place to call home – and fit in your budget.
12 Affordable Neighborhoods in Indianapolis, IN
From the charming Martindale – Brightwood to the cozy Crown Hill, Indianapolis has a variety of neighborhoods with average rents for studio apartments ranging under the city’s average. These Indianapolis neighborhoods have something for all renters.
1. Martindale – Brightwood
2. Crown Hill
3. Irvington
4. Eagledale
5. Arlington Woods
6. South Broad Ripple
7. East Gate
8. East Side
9. Far East Side
10. North High School
11. Valley Mills
12. Crooked Creek
Read on to see what each neighborhood has to offer its residents.
1. Martindale – Brightwood
Average studio rent: $1,115
Average 1-bedroom rent: $675
Apartments for rent in Martindale – Brightwood
Martindale – Brightwood is the most affordable neighborhood in Indianapolis, as the average rent for a one-bedroom unit is $675. There are plenty of reasons to love living in Martindale – Brightwood, from attractions like the Douglass Park Pool to green spaces like Washington Park. This neighborhood is also a historic area, so make sure to explore all the historic homes and architecture.
2. Crown Hill
Average studio rent: $625
Average 1-bedroom rent: $699
Apartments for rent in Crown Hill
Crown Hill is a relaxing area that’s just north of downtown Indianapolis. This affordable neighborhood has lots of attractions such as the Crown Hill Cemetery, The Children’s Museum of Indianapolis, and the Newfields museum. Crown Hill is also close to I-65, so it’s easy to commute into Downtown Indianapolis.
3. Irvington
Average studio rent: $675
Average 1-bedroom rent: $739
Apartments for rent in Irvington
Irvington is the third-most affordable neighborhood in Indianapolis. This neighborhood is an awesome option as it’s near attractions like the Irving Theater and the Benton House. You can find local restaurants and shops along Washington Street, like Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza and Los Cuates Mexican Restaurant. The area also has plenty of historic homes, often in Victorian or Edwardian styles, so it’s excellent for exploring and enjoying Indianapolis. Or, if you’re looking for a relaxing afternoon, you can find Ellenberger Park in the area.
4. Eagledale
Average studio rent: $853
Average 1-bedroom rent: $799
Apartments for rent in Eagledale
Eagledale is the fourth-most affordable neighborhood in Indianapolis. This neighborhood is a great option if you’re looking for access to plenty of shops and restaurants. For example, you can easily access the Eagledale Plaza Shopping Center. There are also a lot of parks in Eagledale, like Moreland Park and Centennial & Groff Park. It’s also next to the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, making it an awesome choice if you want to be close to this famed car racing track.
5. Arlington Woods
Average studio rent: $769
Average 1-bedroom rent: $849
Apartments for rent in Arlington Woods
Arlington Woods is a stellar neighborhood if you want to live a little further outside Downtown. You’ll likely need a car in this neighborhood, so it’s important to consider that if you’re renting. There are also parks nearby, like Pogues Run Art and Nature Park and Roselawn Park.
6. South Broad Ripple
Average studio rent: $799
Average 1-bedroom rent: $894
Apartments for rent in South Broad Ripple
Next up is South Broad Ripple, the sixth-most affordable neighborhood in Indianapolis. South Broad Ripple is full of history and charm with tree-lined streets, historic buildings, and museums, like the Indianapolis Opera and the Indiana State Fairgrounds . This area also has plenty of parks, restaurants, and attractions, so you’ll have lots to explore. Make sure to enjoy the outdoors at Broad Ripple Park or grab a meal at one of the neighborhood restaurants. There’s something for everyone living in South Broad Ripple.
7. East Gate
Average studio rent: $750
Average 1-bedroom rent: $906
Apartments for rent in East Gate
East of downtown, East Gate is the seventh-most affordable neighborhood in Indianapolis. East Gate has a friendly atmosphere and community feel, with plenty of local cafes and restaurants along East 10th Street and Shadeland Avenue, such as Kasai Sushi Bar & Kitchen and Four Seasons Diner.
8. East Side
Average studio rent: $769
Average 1-bedroom rent: $924
Apartments for rent in East Side
East Side takes the eighth spot on our list of most affordable neighborhoods in Indianapolis. Not to be confused with the Eastside area, East Side is located just south of Fort Harrison State Park. The average rent for a one-bedroom unit is roughly $924, making East Side a great option. East Side has plenty of outdoor spaces, like Fort Harrison State Park, which has plenty of fishing and hiking areas. You can also grab a meal at one of the restaurants along Pendelton Pike.
9. Far East Side
Average studio rent: $825
Average 1-bedroom rent: $972
Apartments for rent in Far East Side
A well-known Indianapolis neighborhood, Far East Side is the next area. Far East Side is home to Grassy Creek Regional Park and the Far East Side Neighborhood Center, meaning there’s plenty to do throughout the week. You’ll find several shopping centers in the area, making errands a breeze. If you need to commute to work, there are many options, as the I-465 is nearby.
10. North High School
Average studio rent: $900
Average 1-bedroom rent: $998
Apartments for rent in North High School
The tenth most affordable neighborhood in Indianapolis is North High School, also called Northwest High School. This area has a vibrant feeling with its popular restaurants and quirky shops. You can find parks like Eagle Creek Park and Northwestway Park, perfect for enjoying a sunny day in Indianapolis.
11. Valley Mills
Average studio rent: $929
Average 1-bedroom rent: $999
Apartments for rent in Valley Mills
Number 11 on our list is Valley Mills. This affordable neighborhood is located southwest of downtown Indianapolis and is an awesome area if you’re looking for a neighborhood close to nature. Valley Mills is also close to parks like Southwestway Park and Carson Park. You can find plenty of cozy cafes and lively restaurants along Kentucky Avenue.
12. Crooked Creek
Average studio rent: $824
Average 1-bedroom rent: $1,034
Apartments for rent in Crooked Creek
Taking the 12th spot on our list of affordable neighborhoods in Indianapolis is Crooked Creek. The average rent for a one-bedroom apartment is $1,034, compared to the city’s average of $1,224. This neighborhood is about 10 miles from downtown, which means it’s closer to some other popular neighborhoods, such as Broad Ripple and Meridian-Kessler. Be sure to explore some of the neighborhood’s attractions, like Juan Solomon Park or Broadmoor Country Club.
Methodology: Affordability based on whether a neighborhood has average studio and 1-bedroom rent prices under the city’s average. Average rental data from Rent.com in March 2024.