When Debt Settlement Promised Relief But Delivered a Lawsuit Instead
Michael had been divorced for about a year when the financial reality of his new situation hit hard. The Mandan resident found himself with $32,000 in credit card debt—most of it on a Capital One card he’d been using to cver unexpected expenses during and after his divorce. Living alone now and managing his own bills, Michael realized he was barely making minimum payments, and the balance wasn’t going down.
That’s when he found Freedom Debt Relief online. Their promises sounded hopeful: settle your debts for less than you owe, stop the cycle of minimum payments, and get your financial life back on track. Michael signed up, believing he’d found the best solution to his mounting debt problem.
For 14 months, Michael faithfully paid Freedom Debt Relief $750 every month—a significant chunk of his take-home pay. The company told him they were negotiating with his creditors and building up funds in a special account to eventually settle his debts. Meanwhile, they advised him to stop making payments directly to Capital One and his other creditors.
What Freedom Debt Relief didn’t tell him was that debt settlement companies can’t stop lawsuits. And they can’t guarantee that creditors will even negotiate.
The Day Everything Changed: Served with a Lawsuit
One afternoon, a process server knocked on Michael’s door in Mandan and handed him a legal summons. His heart sank as he read the first page: Schweigert, Klemin & McBride was suing him on behalf of Capital One for the full balance of his credit card debt—over $18,000—plus interest, fees, and attorney costs.
Michael immediately called Freedom Debt Relief. Their response? They couldn’t help with lawsuits. That wasn’t part of their service. If he wanted legal representation, he’d need to hire an attorney separately. Despite paying them $750 a month for over a year—more than $10,000 in total—they offered no protection against the very consequence he’d been trying to avoid.
The lawsuit meant Michael was facing the possibility of a judgment against him. If Capital One won—which seemed likely since the debt was legitimate—they could garnish his wages, freeze his bank account, or put a lien on any property he owned. For someone already stretched thin financially, this was devastating.
Finding the Best Alternative: Walker & Walker Law Offices
Desperate and confused, Michael started researching his options. That’s when he discovered that bankruptcy might actually be the best path forward—not a last resort, but a legal tool designed exactly for situations like his.
He called Walker & Walker Law Offices in Bismarck and spoke with an attorney who took the time to understand his complete financial picture. Unlike the debt settlement company, the attorney was upfront about what bankruptcy could and couldn’t do.
Here’s what Michael learned:
Chapter 7 bankruptcy would immediately stop the lawsuit. The moment his case was filed, something called an “automatic stay” would go into effect. This legal protection would halt all collection actions—including the Schweigert, Klemin & McBride lawsuit—giving him breathing room.
His credit card debt would be completely discharged. Not settled for a percentage. Not negotiated down. Completely eliminated. The $18,000 Capital One debt, plus his other unsecured debts, would be wiped out entirely. The result of the bankruptcy would also not be taxable, unlike debt settlement. In debt settlement, any money that is negotiated down from the original balance counts as taxable income and the borrower gets a 1099. Debt that is discharged in bankruptcy goes away completely without taxes.
The monthly payment would be significantly lower. Instead of $750 per month to Freedom Debt Relief with no guarantees, Walker & Walker offered a payment plan of just $89 every two weeks to cover their attorney fees. That’s roughly $193 per month—less than a third of what he’d been paying the debt settlement company.
The process would be faster. Most Chapter 7 cases in North Dakota are completed within four to six months. Walker and Walker uses best in class processes for streamlining the documents and usually files cases in 2 to 7 days from when we first speak with a client. After that, Michael would be debt-free with a true fresh start.
Why Chapter 7 Was the Best Solution for Michael’s Situation
Michael qualified for Chapter 7 bankruptcy because his income, after accounting for his necessary living expenses, fell below North Dakota’s median income threshold. This is common for people going through divorce who are suddenly managing a household alone on a single income. In 2026, the median income for a single person in North Dakota is $73,549 gross before taxes per year. This is about $35 dollars per hour.
The attorney explained that Chapter 7 is often the best option for people with primarily unsecured debt (credit cards, medical bills, personal loans) who don’t have significant assets to protect beyond basic necessities. Michael owned an older vehicle worth about $8,000 and had basic household belongings—all of which were protected under North Dakota’s bankruptcy exemptions.
Here’s what made bankruptcy the best choice compared to continuing with debt settlement:
Legal Protection: Unlike Freedom Debt Relief, filing bankruptcy immediately stopped the lawsuit through the automatic stay. The collection attorneys had to cease all contact and withdraw their court action.
Certainty: With debt settlement, there’s no guarantee creditors will negotiate or accept settlements. With Chapter 7, eligible debts are discharged by federal law. It’s not a maybe—it’s a legal certainty.
Timeline: Debt settlement programs often take three to four years to complete, and many people drop out before finishing because creditors sue them first. Chapter 7 typically takes four to six months from filing to discharge.
Cost Efficiency: Michael had already paid Freedom Debt Relief over $10,000 with nothing resolved and a lawsuit pending. Walker & Walker’s total fee for handling his Chapter 7 case was approximately $1,500, payable at $89 every two weeks—and this included stopping the lawsuit, preparing all the paperwork, representing him at the creditors’ meeting, and obtaining his discharge.
Credit Impact: Michael worried about his credit score, but his attorney explained something important: debt settlement also damages your credit, often as much or more than bankruptcy. When you stop paying creditors (as debt settlement companies advise), your accounts go delinquent, charge-offs appear, and if you get sued, judgments show up on your credit report. The difference? After bankruptcy, you’re actually debt-free and can start rebuilding immediately.
Michael’s Fresh Start
Michael decided to move forward with Chapter 7 bankruptcy. Walker & Walker filed his case quickly, and within days, the automatic stay stopped the Schweigert, Klemin & McBride lawsuit in its tracks. The collection attorneys had to withdraw their case and cease all contact.
Michael continued his $89 bi-weekly payments to Walker & Walker while his case moved through the court system. About six weeks after filing, he attended his 341 meeting of creditors—a brief, straightforward meeting where the bankruptcy trustee asked him basic questions about his financial situation. His attorney was there with him, and the whole thing took less than ten minutes.
Four months after filing, Michael received his discharge order. All of his unsecured debt—including the Capital One account that had led to the lawsuit—was completely eliminated. No more collection calls. No more lawsuit. No more drowning in minimum payments that never reduced the principal balance.
Today, Michael describes filing Chapter 7 as the best financial decision he could have made post-divorce. Instead of continuing to pay $750 monthly to a debt settlement company that couldn’t protect him from lawsuits, he paid less than half that amount for a few months and ended up completely debt-free.
What This Case Teaches About Debt Relief Options
Michael’s experience highlights an important truth that many people don’t realize until they’re in crisis: debt settlement companies and bankruptcy serve very different purposes, and in many cases, bankruptcy is simply the best tool for the job.
Debt settlement companies cannot:
- Stop lawsuits or wage garnishments
- Provide legal representation
- Guarantee that creditors will negotiate
- Protect you from judgment liens or asset seizure
- Give you a definite timeline for becoming debt-free
Chapter 7 bankruptcy can:
- Immediately stop all collection actions through the automatic stay
- Provide experienced legal representation throughout the process
- Completely discharge eligible debts by federal law
- Protect your essential assets through state and federal exemptions
- Deliver a fresh start in a matter of months, not years
For people facing significant unsecured debt—especially if they’re already being sued or threatened with garnishment—bankruptcy is often not just a good option, but the best option. It’s a legal right designed to give honest people a second chance when they’re overwhelmed by debt through no fault of their own or due to life circumstances like divorce, medical emergencies, or job loss.
Why Walker & Walker Was the Best Choice for Michael
Michael later told his attorney that one of the best parts of working with Walker & Walker was feeling understood rather than judged. As a family-run firm with over 40 years of experience in bankruptcy law, they’ve helped thousands of people in North Dakota through similar situations. They knew exactly how to handle the Schweigert, Klemin & McBride lawsuit, navigate the local Bismarck bankruptcy court procedures, and protect Michael’s rights throughout the process.
The firm’s payment plan approach also made a huge difference. While Michael had been able to scrape together $750 monthly for Freedom Debt Relief, the lower bi-weekly payment of $89 fit his budget better and allowed him to actually afford groceries, utilities, and his basic living expenses while his case was being filed.
If you’re in a similar situation—whether you’ve tried debt settlement without success, you’re facing a lawsuit from a creditor, or you’re simply overwhelmed by debt after divorce or another major life change—the best first step is to talk with an experienced bankruptcy attorney who can explain all your options honestly.
At Walker & Walker Law Offices, we offer free consultations to help you understand whether Chapter 7, Chapter 13, or another approach is the best fit for your specific situation. We’ve seen firsthand how the right legal strategy at the right time can transform someone’s financial future—just as it did for Michael.
Bankruptcy isn’t about giving up. It’s about taking control, using the legal protections available to you, and building the best possible foundation for your financial future. And sometimes, that fresh start is closer—and more affordable—than you think.
Ready to explore your best path forward? Contact Walker & Walker Law Offices today for a free consultation and discover how bankruptcy might be the solution you’ve been looking for.